Premium Hotels in Shelter Island - Find Your Next Luxury Stay

Shelter Island offers attractions like Crescent Beach, while the Shelter Island Ferry brings you to historical spots like the Montauk Point Lighthouse. For outdoor lovers, visit the Mashomack Preserve and enjoy hiking or birdwatching. You'll find a curated selection of hotels, ranging from charming inns to luxurious resorts, all boasting unique features like stunning bay views and easy beach access. Book your stay here for a thoughtfully chosen list of highly-rated accommodations. To save on your trip, consider booking in the spring or fall, and use local taxis or bikes to explore the island.